"Deceived then abandoned" - Lakeview residents on QLDC secrecy
Residents living in Queenstown's Lakeview camping ground say that they were deceived into gifting their cabins to the QLDC and now have been abandoned as their tenancy is being withdrawn.
Two long term residents, Phebe Darkin and Doug Harrap, say they were forced to "gift" their cabins to the council four years ago. Both were worth around $90,000, including improvements, for the cabins that were on council leasehold land.
They then had to pay rent to live in what had been their own house - in spite of receiving nothing for the handover. The only options were to remove the cabins, gift ownership to the QLDC or pay the council $10,000 to have them demolished. Previously the cabin owners had been paying $5,200 a year in rates and ground rent.
Other campground residents who are paying between $200 and $ 300 a week in council rent via Harcourts rental management, say they are being pressured to give up their tenancy with nowhere to go and no clear details on what is happening to their accommodation. With much of the campground in a dilapidated state the tenants have told Crux that the rents are exploitative and unfair.
"We are being told nothing about our future" tenant Jess Hall told Crux after a residents meting last Sunday. That's a view echoed by another tenant, Gatto Fuentes. "We live and work in Queenstown. I pay $300 a week to live here, but nobody is telling us what is going to happen or when. We are only being told that we will be kicked out soon."
Phebe Darkin says she now "has to suffer the indignity" of having Harcourts, on behalf of the QLDC, inspect her house on a regular basis for cleanliness when previously it was her own property. She also says she can't insure her own furnishings and contents because items like her carpets became council property, free of charge, in 2015.
Her neighbour Doug Harrap is in the same position. Originally from Wellington, he was the piano player on the Earnslaw for seven years before retiring. "My place was worth $65,000 but I had to give it to the council for nothing and then pay rent on my own house for the last four years. I'd also invested at least another $20,000 on improving the place. I got nothing from QLDC. The only option was to shift the cabin or pay the council $10,000 to have my own house demolished."
The Lakeview campgrounds were originally gifted to the council for the benefit of the community, but over decades the zoning of the land has gradually been changed so that it can be developed. It was to be the site of a new convention centre but that plan collapsed in 2015 after funding issues and an undertaking from developer Alistair Porter to construct a convention centre at his Remarkables Park site. No work on that project has since taken place.
Now the council plans a massive development that will include at least three hotels and new retail outlets as well as some housing.
The council has been highly secretive about plans for the Lakeview site, beyond announcing that a consortium involving Augusta Capital and Britomart Hospitality Group would be the developers along with a Melbourne company Ninety Four Feet Ltd.
Lucas Giannotti, the General Manager of Sales for Ninety Four Feet, told Crux in late April that the development would involve three luxury hotels and some revolutionary "shared accommodation" buildings. These worker accommodation buildings would involve small rooms, suitable mainly for sleeping, with very large shared communal kitchen and lounge areas. This type of accommodation is gaining traction in big cities overseas where land prices are high and there is a need for mass accommodation at reasonable unit cost.
Beyond announcing the development partners, the QLDC has been extraordinarily secretive about the Lakeview details, even though plans are clearly well advanced, based on information from Mr Giannotti who flew into Queenstown with a number of Australian colleagues on April 24th.
Lakeview residents spoken to by Crux say that the combination of secrecy, pressure to end their tenancies and what they see as a cavalier attitude to their future by the council, is cruel, insensitive and unkind. One resident told Crux that they plan to stay in their cabin "until the bulldozers arrive."
Mayor Jim Boult issued the following detailed statement to Crux in response to the Lakeview residents claims.
"There is a fairly extensive history with Lakeview that goes well before my time as Mayor but in principle Council has always intended that this highly valuable community site be developed.
This knowledge has been extensively and historically canvased with tenants and in terms of Council’s return (financial and non-financial) for the site, you might say we were neglecting our duty to ratepayers if we continued to enable such a valuable site to reap such a minor return. Based on the land value alone, the holding cost exceeds the current income from cabins. However it is the opportunity to deliver increased (additional) housing supply on the site, through intensified land use, that is driving the Council decision to remove some of the cabins at this time. The primary outcome being to establish a thriving residential-focused mixed use precinct within close proximity to the Queenstown town centre. Council anticipated this in 2002 when it purchased approximately half the cabins and provided a licence to occupy (which expired in September 2015) for the remaining privately owned cabins.
When the site was put to the market in 2006, the GFC meant that Council wisely set this process to one side until the market returned. Meantime we have enable the cabins to continue to be occupied to ease the lower end market but as you have seen many are reaching the point where they are not fit for occupation. Having said that Council has invested in many of the cabins over the last few years. I have been provided with the following background:
- The cabins (previously owned privately) had a 12-15 year licence to occupy, that expired on 30 September 2015.
- Under the licence it was the cabin owner’s obligation to remove their cabin.
- Cabin owners were given the option of: Removing their cabin; Have QLDC remove their cabin (estimated cost $10k); or Transferring ownership of their cabin to QLDC. Those who did transfer ownership but remained as tenants did so with the clear understanding that the arrangement could not be permanent. The rent prior to the transfer and post the transfer remained unchanged for pensioners’ $5200 p.a.
- The majority of cabin owners took up the transfer option (3.c) and some owners (who lived in their cabin) also opted to become tenants in full knowledge that this arrangement was not intended to be permanent.
- The Council has acknowledged through the Lakeview development process that the buildings are approaching the end of their economic and habitable life and will need replacement or major works in the near future should they be retained. In the year to date (to 30 Apr 19), repairs and maintenance on the properties has totalled $152,751+GST whilst in the 2017/18 financial year $160,047 was spent.
- The Council is currently underway with insulation upgrades for those cabins being retained short to medium term.
- I reject the term ‘exploitative rents’ completely. There may not have been a lot of choice in the market but tenants have opted to live in the cabins. Tenancy Services list 1-2 bedroom in the lower range at $550 in Queenstown. The Lakeview cabins are $250-300 p.w. for 1-2 bed cabins.
- The old Lakeview Motels are not in a fit state to be let accommodation. They have no independent plumbing, bathrooms, kitchens etc.
Key points regarding what we are doing to support tenants through this process:
- Our starting premise has been that we need to wrap support around this process and give ample notice (six months). Our approach is that if we can retain cabins and they can meet standards then we will do so in the short to medium term.
- We have been keeping local social agencies informed of the proposed development of Lakeview and how this may affect tenants; asking agencies with Lakeview tenant clients to work with their clients on a plan, if they are not able to continue living at Lakeview – these include Ministry of Social Development, Age Concern, Lakes Distict Hospital social worker and community mental health, Uruuruwhenua Health, Happiness House, PACT mental health service and Salvation Army.
- We advised all tenants on 18 April of the opportunity to apply to stay in one of the remaining Lakeview cabins – the Lakeview Tenant Accommodation Assessment.
- This process is being managed in partnership with the Queenstown Lakes Community Housing Trust (QLCHT) and the Ministry of Social Development (MSD) Work and Income Queenstown. Information about this process is available on the QLDC website: https://www.qldc.govt.nz/our-community/lakeview-information-for-tenants/
- As of last week over 70 applications had been received from tenants. A follow up letter was sent last week to those tenants who haven’t applied to advise that applications must be submitted by 31 May.
- The applications for the Lakeview Tenant Accommodation Assessment will be assessed by QLCHT and MSD, who will allocate the available cabins based on need. All applicants will be advised by early July of the outcome.
- We further plan to run an accommodation workshop with Harcourts and other providers to support tenants who are not allocated a cabin to support them in finding alternate location.
- The Queenstown Chamber of Commerce is planning a workshop with employers to discuss housing issues in Queenstown.
- Council is continuing to progress a Housing Strategy for the District.
I would add that we have thought long and hard about how we can support these folk. The upheaval that some will face is not lost on this Council. Ultimately as I have said the site has not offered a permanent solution to tenants choosing to reside there more than a decade. This day was always going to come.
One important aspect here is that in anticipation of the disruption to the lower end accommodation market and concern for some of the vulnerable tenants the entire Lynch Block has always been set aside from the Lakeview development deal with the ability to retain cabins there and the opportunity to consider this block potentially for some form of residential offering, beyond the short to medium term. Council could have reasonably opted to also dispose of the Lynch Block now.
In terms of the individuals you have met with, we are not prepared to discuss individuals for privacy reasons, but I am assured that support will be given to those most in need.
With regard to your conversation with Mr Giannotti, the majority of the development is residential, as outlined. There are hotels being proposed but nothing at the luxury level. This detail will soon be available (we hope to release this at the end of June)."
Queenstown Chamber of Commerce CEO Anna Mickell told Crux:
"The Chamber was formally notified by several different teams at QLDC some months ago about their concern for the well-being of residents living on the Lakeview land. I was briefed with respect to those residents who were working locally. I am not able to comment on the situation of non-working residents, except to say that I saw evidence of the fact that there was a separate, concerned and resourced work stream to care for these folk, in conjunction with central government agencies.
The Chamber has worked to ensure that employers understand that some of their staff may be affected by this change and they should be on the look out for evidence of hardship. However, for privacy reasons, it was not appropriate to directly approach any affected working resident with offers of assistance.
The quality and density of these dwellings speak for themselves. It is the Chamber's view that QLDC has no choice but to deliver on the community's expectations of dry, comfortable and sustainable housing and they need to push on."
Main Image - from left: Lakeview residents Phebe Darkin, Gatto Fuentes, Jess Hall and Doug Harrap.